We're locals who are regulars at Carelli's. It has a wonderful atmosphere - fireplace warm and invitiing in winter, and huge windows that open to the outdoors in summer. The food is consistently good, and it's an insiders secret that they make one of the best burgers in town. However, it's hard to order a burger when there are so many other delicious options. I love the appetizer mussels (which I have as an entree), the eggplant parmesan, Greek salad, dessert crepes ... and the list goes on. My husband loves the pasta dishes. We generally sit at the bar and the service is always friendly and prompt. My husband had his office dinner here in December, and our party of 14 was treated just as promptly and courteously as we are when we sit at the bar. Everyone from the office thoroughly enjoyed their dinner and said they'd love to return. That's just what we keep doing!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.