Went to Penny Ice Creamery over the weekend with a group of friends. Now I love ice cream but this place was really a stretch for me. They had a limited number of flavors (maybe 12) and most were not appealing to me. Beet Hibiscus flavor, really? How about bitter caramel? Now, if you like this kind of off-the-wall flavor, want glutton free cones, etc., you are their target audience. But not me or the group I was with. I tried the fresh mint chip. The flavor was okay but not very rich and creamy. I only ate half the cone, which I never do. Service was meh. I'll try a different place next time I am in Santa Cruz.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.