If only I lived nearby, I would go daily. One of my favorite food stops in the world. I never go near Tomales Bay without stopping here. It is an important ritual and it should be yours too. The BBQ oysters are simply divine. Tried the Fish Stew this past time and it was equally well prepared. The are juicy, perfectly prepared and the flavors of their sauces are downright delicious. Served with tangy hot fresh Sourdough bread. We tried the raw Kumamoto as well and they were super fresh and as good as they usual. I do think the Preston Point are best BBQ'd than raw. But, I will not tarnish this review with anything but glowing opinion of their food. Also the atmosphere is great - casual and right on the bay so killer views. Patrons from all around the world, some friendly. Can't recommend it more. Never tried the other places so I can't compare. I just know Marshall Store is so reliable why tempt disappointment with another.