Had an enjoyable dinner here just before Thanksgiving. Having worked in Italy off and on for a number of years, I was surprised how little the food was Americanized. Pizza was thin and crispy, pastas were delicious. The wine list is extensive with many offerings from Italy segregated by Northern, middle and Southern. If too overwhelming, the staff is happy to make a recommendation based on your preferences and courses.
The staff, too numerous to count, was very quick and attentive, willing to engage you and chat up the table. The atmosphere is very cozy and inviting, making It's Italia a wonderful place for dinner. It's a hopping place.
The place was packed on the Tuesday night we were there, suggesting they are really doing something right. It appears they also have take out as we saw several people with packaged meals leaving.
I'd highly recommend this great addition to Half Moon Bay. Well done!