It is pricey but as a born in NY Jewish person I found Milton's to be authentic NY Jewish style deli. My guy and I each had the soup and 1/2 sandwich special. We both chose matzah ball soup and it was the best we ever had- loaded with noodles, chunks of chicken , carrots and a huge matzah ball. It definitely tasted homemade. It was served with pickels and a little loaf of challa bread. I then had lean corned beef on rye and my guy had pastrami on rye. My corned beef was excellent. I admit he was not as crazy about his pastrami , but so what. Maybe it was too lean.
Oh yes, we waited about 20 min for a table during which time there was courtesy coffee and mini muffins. Also the place is ultra clean, upscale and fun looking. Soup and half sandwiches, one diet coke and bill was abt $33.00 including tax plus tip.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.