We were in Monticello on business matters. To find such a wonderful restaurant in this town was a shock! This is TRUE italian, people! The chef/owner walks around and talks to his customers! He remembered us when we came in the second time. Yes, in 4 days, we ate there twice! We had the Eggplant Rollatini app. Oh, my! Get it! Get two! Get one to go! Stuffed Mushrooms were very good. Caesar Salad was good, too. Eggplant Parmigiana will have you licking the plate. Sauce is excellent! Shrimp Scampi- delicious! We had Tiramisu on our last visit and it was really good! Desserts are not made in house, but it was worth the calories! Didn't bother ordering the Community Coffee (yuck!). I strongly suggest they invest in some Lavazza Coffee, it would make a great ending to a fantastic meal. Wait staff was Fair the first night, but our server was about 16 and had no idea about Italian food. The second night we had a seasoned server who was just excellent! Oh, you can get a drink at suppertime only- it's a dry town:).
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.