We were recommended by our innkeeper to go to this restaurant while staying in Eureka and we had a great meal. We did have something of a wait (~40 minutes) even though we did not arrive until almost 8 pm. But they have a room set up where you can play board games during wait times which made it pass quickly and allowed my husband and I to have some quiet relaxation time after a busy day learning town. I had the parmesan chicken and he had the flounder special. Both of which we enjoyed tremendously. We had bread with roast garlic and butter for a starter and salads which our waiter kindly gave us two types of dressings on the side to try. And these were big portions too! You may need a to go box! The only real negative that I had was that they accidentally brought me diet instead of regular soda...twice. But it was pretty much standing room only when it happened and they did come fix it right away. Also our total check came to only about $55 including drinks so that is one of our least expensive dinner meals here in Eureka. So if you like itialian food...come on down to Ermilio's! I know that when I come back, I sure will!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.