I'd heard that Cafe Margarita was terrible. The "reviews" I'd been told were terrible. It was quite nice. My mother is still talking about how good the chicken parm was.
The most important part, though, was that on Friday and Saturday evenings, Juan de Granada is there. He is one of the most gifted guitar players you will ever encounter. I've been following him, going to the various places he has appeared for nearly 17 years. Cafe Margarita is the nicest.