Ate here twice and loved the simplicity and family run aspect of Altin Tava.
The reason for the review title? Well it's not the most polished of restaurants, has a limited menu and some may say it's a bit too spartan. You also need to like cats (we do btw).
In some respects it would be great to see the owners invest in doing the property up and becoming even more successful but we think that would possibly affect the rustic and homely nature, hence the 'quandary'.
Very glad we visited when we did and would definitely go back in a future visit just to see how things develop.