Been there about 2 years ago when the place was new if i'm not mistaken (yeah rating my trips from the past was on my 2014 to-do list). We actually stayed in one of the two cabanas next to the restaurant and we enjoyed it very much. The owner (taylor i guess) was very nice and cooked us some great meals. He is also a certifide guide and he guided us to see the turtles wich was a very pleasant activity. He told us a lot about how it was growing up in Tortuguero.
Definitely recommend this place