We've been there three times so far and might go again before we leave!
Our first night we arrived quite late (around 8.30pm) and wanted something after a long bus journey. This place was two doors away from our hotel (Mayol lodge) and the experience was great from start to finish. We got a warm welcome from the staff, feee nacho chips with dips and water as soon as we sat down. They recommended dishes, the caribbean chicken casado and rice and beans with chicken, both of which we took and were delicious. The chicken was really tasty and moist, huge portions which i couldn't finish.
The following two mornings we had breakfast there which was also great, eggs, tortillas and coffee for 2 dollars! Plus we got a plate of fruit for free!
This is definitely one of the better meals i have had in costa rica and the friendly staff also make the experience worth repeating!
It is just one block back from the square behind the big supermarket, along from soda visquez.