Our MN crew stayed in a house down the beach in Sandy Bay the first week of January. We had the good fortune of finding the Blue Bahia on our second nite and had several excellent meals at this nice establishment. The banana pancakes and omelets were a great way to start the day. The shrimp, lobster, and freshly smoked brisket were an excellent way to finish it. The wine and drinks were very good too. Don't miss the Elvis Presley roll for dessert (although your stomach may not have enough room). The owner is very pleasant, although he's a "Cheese Head" Packer fan. Randy, the waiter, makes things fun, and is hyper-efficient. We will definitely return on future trips to the island.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.