This was my first time to Carmella's and it was a very pleasurable dining experience. Unlike most reviews, I did not have to wait for the extremely long lines but I also went outside of normal dining rush hours.
Overall, the food was phenominal, the service was exceptional, and the wine menu is extensive. The manager made sure to check with everyone to see how their dining experience was and offered any assistance when needed. They have daily meal and dessert specials which allow for other options outside of the menu.
Definately will be visiting this establishment every chance I make it back to Appleton!!!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.