My husband and I have eaten at Carmella's 5 or 6 times now both by ourselves and with friends. In all cases the food was delicious and the service very good. We've tried a variety of items but our favorites are the tomato/fresh mozzerella/prociutto starter, rigatoni with spinach in a tomato cream sauce, and the bucatini (lamb ragu). The flavors/sauces are excellent!
We find the atmosphere quite warm and cozy but do agree that it can get quite noisy when full.
Our only con is that it does get pricey. Salads run about $8, appetizers $12, and entrees anywhere from $12 - 26 depending on what you get. I wish they would at least include a side salad with any entree but salads are all seperate.
We love the food here and wish we could eat here more often but for us it is a special occasion restaurant due to cost. We'll keep coming for birthdays and anniversaries though!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.