My husband and I ate here on Wednesday evening. They were not as busy as usual, so we decided to give it a try after hearing from several people that Time Square was really great. Maybe it was the day, or new staff, or some other malfunction, but our pizza was far from impressive.
The pizzas that can be ordered by the slice at the counter looked like they had been there for hours...cold and congealed, with dried out toppings, so we decided to order a whole pizza. We ordered ham and pineapple, what could go wrong?
It was brought to our table piping hot, which was great. I notice right a way that the crust had a really nice texture, but then followed with absolutely no flavor, not even a cardboard-like flavor. The cheese and ham were sparse, but the pineapple was plentiful, if you like entire rings of canned pineapple on your pizza, this is the place for you. Canned pineapple is fine, but this pineapple had no flavor and was almost white in color, as if canned way before ripe.
We really had high hopes for Time Square pizza, perhaps our expectations were too high.
On the bright side, the staff was friendly and their sanitation grade was a 96.
Maybe their other food is better, if we return I will try one of their other Italian dishes.