Okay, two things you should know before reading my review of this place - # I am an Italian girl from the Bronx, New York and #2 - my first meal was a pizza - okay so the second one isn't really true but I think I have eaten more pizza in my life than anything else and I have to say, I am so happy I found this place! We have been looking for a great pizza place in the area and tried many of the others which I won't mention here but let's just say they do put New York in their name and while they are pretty good, they are not better than J&S.
Even my husband who used to own his own pizzeria back home said this pizza was one of the best he had here and reminded him of our pizza in New York. I will say it was a tad bit on the salty side but I was able to overlook that. The crust was crunchy, crispy, just thick enough and the cheese and sauce were authentic and yummy. We ordered a large pie with our favorite toppings, sausage and mushroom. The mushrooms were fresh, NOT CANNED - Big + in my book and the sausage was sliced thin and had a great flavor. Let me tell you, they are so generous with the toppings here! Our pizza was absolutely loaded with toppings! We ordered from one of the other "New York" pizzerias and had to use a magnifying glass to find our toppings and they charged about the same amount of money.
As another reviewer noted, the place isn't much to look at but who cares??? If I want ambiance, I will go to a fancy Italian restaurant - not a pizzeria!
J&S, you found some new customers here!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.