My partner and I spent 3 nights at Elif Star, and had a great time. The staff were extremely friendly - helping us with restaurant recommendations, hiking tips, and even found a shuttle bus for us to get to our flight (when the bus companies said no shuttle buses were running at that time!). Plus, the view from our room was beautiful.
The heater in our room was broken (but we just used an extra blanket), and sometimes there was no hot water in the bathroom, but those were minor issues. I'd definitely consider staying here again.