I think if we ever went back to Madurai, we would stay somewhere else. Having looked at its website we had gained a slightly misleading impression. The room was pretty clean, but the bathroom had a fairly strong, rancid smell, we couldn't tell if it was the drains or the shower curtain.
The windows in our room didn't fit properly in their frames, so we could clearly hear the busy traffic outside and the constant honking.
It is a good way out of the centre of the city, you need a tuk tuk to get to the temples. However, the Gandhi museum is only a 10-15 minute walk away.
The staff were ok, but not as friendly or welcoming as other places on our trip. The breakfast food was again only ok.