I've diners at Old Homestead many times and was looking forward to their prime rib. Unfortunately, this time it was pretty awful. We waited forever for our entrees and when they arrived, it was obvious my prime rib had been sitting under a heat lamp. Completely dry, chewy and flavorless. My partner's steak was perfect and I'm thinking they goofed up her order and parked mine while they remade hers. Sides, cocktails and service were as good as always and I will certainly give them another chance.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.