Not great. We shared a Robalo al Ajillo which was a good sized piece of fish, very tasty, but served with uninspired vegetables and very sweet coconut rice. The shrimp ceviche was in a word, disgusting, with kind of a pickled acidic taste. Service was good, prices are reasonable but not cheap. Don't be fooled, it's always full, but there are many better (and cheaper) places in Cartagena.