My husband and I visited Madaket beach at the end of this summer – the week after labor day. The only shuttle going this week was to this beach. To our delight we were dropped off in front of Millie’s and got take out from them for lunch one day. I ordered the 40th Pole quesadilla – it was amazing! It was huge and stuffed with grilled marinated chicken, goat cheese, caramelized onions, and jack & cheddar cheese. Next time we are on the island we will be sure to come back here! One tip is to check the schedule during the off season – we lucked out that we went a day they were open.