I'd definitely recommend this restaurant and would come again as it was our favorite dinner during our stay in Nantucket this summer! Everything from the atmosphere to the food was great. We had a group of 8 and got a table in a room upstairs that was shared with one other bigger party. I can't speak on behalf on each individual dish everyone got, but everyone did love their choices! Several of us had the roasted red and gold beet salad, which was great as an appetizer. I had the Murray's Farms Breast of Chicken. The savory bread pudding that came with it with a watermelon feta salad and pomegranate honey was awesome! Several others got the Sautéed Local Cod that had a delicious crust on It while being perfectly flaky on the inside. Although I didn't taste it, one other person in our group had the seasonal vegetable risotto, and it looked amazing!