For the price during the peak season and holidays you can't beat it. Yes it's out dated, yes Haziel is strange but its comfy and walking distance to everything on the island. There's no AC in the carriage house , few places actually have it. Power is super expensive out there, it's just not a necessity. It's a small room with a bathroom and shower. No tv, a few windows. The inn keeper pushes his religious and political beliefs a tad too much. Just grin and bear it, if you were stuck on a 20sq mi island forever you would be a little weird too. Breakfast is nice. Homemade muffins (they're amazing) cereal and coffee. It's great. We ate it then walked to a spot for a cup of coffee and a view. I proposed in July, never having been to the island, Haziel helped me set up all the spots I wanted to hit and the boat I wanted to propose on. Very helpful. That stay was only an overnight. Our next trip was the end of August with another couple, there were 4 of us total and again he was very accommodating. We stayed 3 days. I would go back, I would however like to see another b&b. remember if you go to Nantucket you're not staying in the room your visiting all of Nantucket's wonderful hidden treasures, the carriage house will help keep some green in your wallet! Oh and it's spotless, you will not find a spec of dust anywhere!