I thought Casanovas was great. We had just finished the LONG Road to Hana and I had researched this place before we flew out to Maui. Absolutely great. The service was good..and the pizza (and I'm from the NY area) was delicious (granted, this isn't the Northeast but this was by FAR the best pizza I had on the island). It's brick oven style, which is even better. My friend had the pasta and that was good too. The chocolate cake - mmmm! I highly recommend this place if you're looking for good Italian in Maui. It's worth the drive if you're not staying near Makawao.