We chose to pay $40 for a private boat to take us to Water Cay. There are many signs in Utila advertising this trip to shop around for the best price.
Water Cay was beautiful and was one of the highlights for me whilst at Utila. The sand is pure white and the sea pure blue. We took snorkels but found the water too shallow to properly swim around the coral so that was a slight disaster.
Be careful with paying the caretaker. We paid 15 to our boat captain who passed on the money, because on the island they make you pay 50 and then supposedly skim off the top.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.