We just spent one night at the Atwater, but I found nothing at all to complain about. If you want some nitpicking... the bathroom door handle only worked when turned to the left. How's that for nitpicking? The room was fine. Nicely painted, clean and quiet with an un-dramatic view, but we did pick one of the cheaper rooms on the third floor, (we could have been on the second floor for the same price) and there's no elevator. The staff was just fine. The beds and pillows were comfortable. No complaints! I'd go back, but for me Catalina is kind of a 'if you've seen it once...' kind of place.
- Free Wifi
- Breakfast included