If you don't want to read further this sums it up: Best time to be had on Catalina Island.
I surprised my girl with a trip to Catalina on her B-day, and decided for an overnight stay to be able to get more out of the island. Chip, 3rd generation islander and owner of Wet Spot rentals took us on an outback picnic tour one of the days.
As every reviewer has said, except the one who will give a business a poor review based on weather, the tour is a blast, and you really have to experience it for yourselves. Chip was very informative on all aspects of the islands history and had plenty of great stories about growing up on the island. Lunch is provided, but we brought our own adult beverages.
Saw several Bison, a rattlesnake, seals, eagles and plenty of beautiful scenery. Got to kayak around for a few hours and check out all the coves and rocks around Little Harbor. There are other tours to take, and things to do on the island, but this one is the absolute best!