A few things before I get to the food:
The reservation system - you can only book 20 days out online, not via phone, so when I did that I was only offered a seat at 6-7pm or after 8.30pm (neither were preferable), so I chose the 7pm seating which they inform has a 2.5hour seating time. Yet on the night the restaurant was hardly busy and by 9pm it was over half empty. We well overstayed the 2.5hour mark which means that I could have booked my preferred 7.30pm or 8pm booking which was frustrating. This also meant you can't select the (much coveted) seats at the bar, we sat near the door in the restaurant and couldn't see the kitchen from where we were.
The space was FREEZING. It was a lovely balmy Autumn night in Sydney so we didn't bring jackets. By the fourth course, I was cold, the air con swirling around our ankles. By the sixth I was shivering and by dessert we asked to move to the bar and I had to have a glass of hot water to warm me up. Though the staff were very attentive and apologetic about this (and sadly they can't control this themselves) I can't help but feel it tainted my experience. I have never been that cold in a nice restaurant before - it completely ruined the ambiance, so please take a warm jacket!
The drinks pairing is excellent – you get a good selection of Sake, spirits and wines to complement well. It’s nice to try things you wouldn’t normally have.
The food is a degustation menu- which you receive a printed version of at the end (it would be nice to get this at the start with the paired drinks menu) so you can muse over it all night. Classic degustation, where 5 of the "dishes" were a single morsel of food. Hardly a course. We made the mistake of reading a 2013 "Not Quite Nigella" review of this place, so we were excited for dishes that never eventuated. We were expecting more an Asian feel, but it really wasn't.
There were 4 standout dishes for us:
• A delicious juicy crab mix, in a fruity/nutty pepperberry cracker
• The hand made roti and onion jam that came with the chicken confit salad (which was quite bland except the pan fried jerk skin)
• The exceptional yabby (that they bring to your table when you arrive – alive), these were so fresh and delicious they literally melted in our mouths.
• The carrot three ways, with flavour punches of braised oxtail.
All the other savouries were pretty “meh”, particularly the pork which was a bit dry and served with some very plain black eyed pea mix (the $16 café baked beans I had the next morning where 100% more interesting).
Desserts, again, where pretty underwhelming. One cool thing being a raisin crispbread, which was just a very thin layer of raisin jam spread out into large crispy shards, which was lovely with the savoury flavours of the “conkie”. To give you an idea, when we left – we went straight across to Zumbo, and shared a box of Macaroons and they were more of a highlight.
Yes, we went to Zumbo, mainly because we were still hungry. 15 “courses” across 3+ hours would have totalled about 250gm of food all up, so if you are a big eater – plan your midnight snack before you go.
We did receive 5 star/3 hatted SERVICE, the floor staff were lovely and knowledgeable about each dish and wine pairing, and the chefs all look at each other nervously when people go to the bathroom – we saw them throw away a few things and start again after too long a delay. Management could alleviate this problem though, by adding a second bathroom.
All in all, my review seems quite negative but when you are paying over $300 per head you should expect extremely high standards. This was a special occasion for us, my partner had wanted to go for years, so I am certainly glad we experienced this, overall the food was good and it was a lovely night. But would we go back – no.