Nothing but good words about Peace and Plenty. Had an amazing experience at this lovely hotel. From the staff, food, room and location. I would definitely go back. I would recommend this place to our family and friends.

I loved everything about this property. The location, our room, the staff, the food and the cleanliness. I will definitely be back! We only stayed two nights. Next time I will plan on staying at least four.

Some good, some bad. We loved the beach club and had some absolutely delicious burgers and pina coladas there! Staff at the beach club were upbeat and really fun. There were lots of laughing and dancing, it was a blast and the beach is gorgeous! Good location, central in Georgetown. The rooms were clean and the AC worked great (two very important things!). However, no phone in the room to call the front desk was a bit peculiar, but not the end of the world. Staff at the main hotel were hit or miss, some were really nice and outgoing and remembered your name (Misty), and some were polite enough to pass but had a bit of a standoffish attitude. As Exuma is a small island, it is understandable that a lot of menu items at the restaurant are not always available, however it was a little frustrating at times. We paid for breakfast combos that were supposed to include juice but never got juice at either day we ate breakfast. Many dinner items were unavailable as well. We opted to eat in town as much as possible which led us to try a lot of good local dishes. Unfortunately, we had an issue with the car rental service they are connected with, "Affordable Car Rental." I could not find proof of this company online, and the interaction with them ruined the end of our trip. We rented a car, put down the mandatory $100 deposit, and paid for insurance for the days we had the vehicle. We came out of the beach to find the car in the parking lot had a busted tail light. No note left behind, no idea what happened. As tourists, we had no way to call police to report this (no wifi or data at tropic of cancer) and we decided to drive back to the hotel to seek assistance. We sent the rental company pictures of the car at the scene, and the damage. They told us they would come down that evening to talk to us about the damage and what we need to pay them. 3 hrs later they finally showed up, quickly eye balled the damage and told us it was going to cost $430 and WE had to pay them on the spot because we didn't call the police when we first found the damage so for all they know "the damage was our fault." We ended up paying them $200 for the damage and they talked us down from calling the police. We just paid to get them to leave (they were shady, honestly), and end the whole ordeal. In hindsight, we probably should have gotten the police involved. The P&P manager was notified who is working on dealing with this issue with the rental company, though he says he cannot promise much. If you stay at P&P, please be wary of their rental car assistance. Book elsewhere!! This totally ruined our last night and makes us not want to return!