We dined here twice during our recent trip to St. John and were happy with the results each time. The daily fresh catch selections, each offered in four different preparations, were terrific, though we were disappointed during our second visit to learn that the restaurant had run out of mahi mahi. Our son had the barbeque platter and he was quite impressed. Our one complaint: the swordfish, which was a fresh catch selection on each of our visits, seemed less fresh. Service was fine, prices were inflated (as is the norm on STJ). We'll dine here again on our next visit and would recommend the restaurant to others.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.