We went early for sunset, but unfortunately some clouds blocked the sun right around sunset. The drinks at the bar were so good & we loved the Hibiscus coconut rum! When we sat, the hostess put us at the best table with a perfect view of the water! (Thank you!) The service was excellent, the food was elegant & flavorful. We had a great meal and will be back when we visit the island again in the future.

Really overrated. Atmosphere was nice, as we sat outside. I had the burger and fries. Fries good, the burger meat was small and didn’t taste like a burger.

Great place for lunch, but not a fancy dinner.

We were staying in a vrbo nearby and heard so many great things about Spice Mill so we saved this dinner for our last night of vacation. Beautiful setting on the beach and well decorated. The flies were bad and I feel like the restaurant could do something to deter them? Hard to enjoy a nice meal when flies are lingering. Maybe it was just on the night we visited because the air was still? The food was very good…slightly overpriced for what it is…but expected at a touristy restaurant. Service was slow and not the friendly vibe we felt on the island during the rest of our stay. We have food allergies and they acknowledged them but almost seemed annoyed by them. My son’s are life threatening so the “meh” attitude toward them was troubling. Overall, food was great but the service could use some help. And you are definitely on island time so enjoy the scenery and expect a longer meal.

i visit spice mills on Wednesday, bar staff was not friendly thanks to my amazing waitress natisha she was very pleasant my family and i was very pleased with her service ✅

We arrived a little early for our reservation but despite available tables, we waited 45 min before being escorted to our table- at least 30 min after our appointed reservation. Service was just extra extra extra slow with a tasteless salad and overpriced seafood cake. Mahi mahi was delicious and lobster pasta just ok. If you are staying at Park Hyatt, go- otherwise not worth the nighttime drive