My wife and I ate there last week, after reading all of the great reviews on this site. I was a little disappointed overall by our evening there, by the food as well as the selection. When we went to order, we were told that a lot of the daily specials were already out (2 of the appetizers, 1 of the entrees and 2 of the desserts were no longer available) - most of those were items we were planning to order initially.
I ordered the foie de lotte (monkfish liver) and did not like the taste of it at all. I've had monkfish liver before and enjoyed it, but this one tasted off. My wife ordered the caillettes, and did not like the consistency of those too much either. The entrees were ok, but not more. Maybe we did not order the right dishes... Service was excellent, however.