My husband and I stayed at Casa Selita for four nights without the kids. We loved it and can't wait to go back! The best part about Casa Selita is Selita herself: warm, gregarious, generous, candid and helpful. Selita told us where to go for dinner each night, and we loved every single place. She took us to Civita di Bagnoregio for a private tour since she had the time (for an extra fee). She told us about her life and her activities, which we found interesting and inspiring. And she gave us tips on where to go in the Dolomites (where she grew up) on our next trip.
We loved the location of Casa Selita. It was only a 5-10 minute walk to the walled city, with an easy elevator ride up. Best of all, when you stay at Selita's you enter the city directly into the old town, not the touristy area where the funicular lets off. And when you're at Casa Selita, you're surrounded by trees, flowers, and grass and the beautiful hillsides surrounding Orvieto. The location was ideal.
Our room was lovely. I forget the name, but it was on the left-most side of the main building as you face the staircases. It had a big, four-poster bed plus a private balcony. It was very comfortable and felt private.
Breakfast was very good -- my only (very small) complaint would be the lack of fresh fruit and the fact that breakfast was exactly the same every day. But we had bread, cheese, ham, cereal, milk, juice, coffee and more. Much better than the "breakfast" at our next hotel, which was just a packaged croissant, coffee, and milk.
Casa Selita was a great value for the money.
We dream of going back to Casa Selita, and when we do, we plan to use it as our home base to visit Rome, in addition to spending time in Orvieto.