We recently stayed in Paphos for a week and were staying along Tomb of the Kings. We ate here twice during our stay, once later on in the evening when it was busy and secondly we went back for an early tea (5pm) as we had the flight home to catch and wanted something nice to eat before heading off home.
Both times we ate we enjoyed it, although initially we were put off by the guy outside trying to lure you in. Part of the reason I enjoyed this meal is that I am quite a fussy vegetarian and they had a spinach and feta pie on the menu. I had this on both visits and enjoyed it equally both times. It came with a nice side salad and a portion of chips (and these weren't the thin french fries that we found many restaurants in Paphos served). My husband particularly enjoyed the kleftiko on the first visit and was equally satisfied with the chicken kebab during our second stay.
Given the choice, the atmosphere is better later in the evening. There is also a very friendly waitress and the restaurant is very clean. I would definately recommend and would return.