Our first venture to eating out in Reykjavik, a light lunch in the middle of town. There are so many places to choose from. We wanted something light. I had a "scandinavian" open steak sandwich while my wife had a Caesar's salad. all washed down with their local ale. Good value for money. Service was superb, our waiter really showed an interest in where we were from, what we'd planned etc.
Atmosphrere was fine but I probably wouldn't choose it for an evening meal (there are better options).