We enjoyed our stay here. The location was great (across the river in Oltrarno), room was spacious and the price was reasonable. A small complaint: the shower could have used some paint and maybe a better scrubbing. We loved the location because it was in a quieter part of town, away from the hordes, next door to the Boboli Gardens and up the street from some great restaurants. We are city dwellers used to walking, so it only took us 10 minutes to walk to the Ponte Vecchio, 20 minutes to the Accademia Museum. Our room had a kitchenette, which was nice, because I took a pasta making class one day and I cooked the pasta for dinner. It was also economical to store snacks and drinks in our small fridge.
Warning: Ignore the staff's restaurant suggestions -- they sent us to a horrible tourist trap.