We were really excited about visiting Lochner because of all the amazing reviews. However, although the setting was quaint, we were a bit disappointed all round. Firstly, the menu was quite confusing as we weren't sure whether or not we could mix and match from different options, so we had to ask the waitress to explain it. Secondly, we were expecting the food to be out of this world, but I'm sorry to say that we found it quite average, considering the cost. It also felt a little like the waitress was trying to hard sell things at times, including dessert, which we didn't want. We also had an interesting debate about German cheese, which she said was fantastic but then couldn't name or offer us any!
Sorry - I wish we could give it a higher rating.