I should have known by the outside that Lefty's was not the place to eat, but TripAdvisor did rate it the # 1 Pizza Restaurant in Grand Falls so I decided not to judge a book by it's cover! Once past the front door I was transported back in time to the pizza joints of the 60's with checkered tablecloth's and tacky Italian memorabilia.
Still hoping for the best I could forgive the surroundings to experience "The pizza and the owners are by far the best in the province. They make their own dough on the premises and excellent toppings of only the finest ingredients." to quote another review. I decided to try their best pie with a Small Extra Special - complete with Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Green Pepper and Bacon!
The pizza arrived in a reasonable time and looked good on first glance. The tasting however revealed canned mushrooms, frozen pieces of green pepper, and imitation bacon bits! What a let down! Though the outer crust was thick and crisp the center was thin enough to read through and unable to support the toppings covering it.
I'll chalk this one up to experience and recommend Lefty's be left be.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.