First off, I will say that this place is somewhat priced higher than what we normally allow in our budget, so for us we went here to celebrate some major event between us. Discovering Goodfellas was a surprise because my husband and I just happened upon it while going for a walk on Bloor. I was curious to see if it delivered on its signage about it being rated the best pizza. My past experience with at least three other places with wood oven pizzas made me suspect that Goodfellas pizza would deliver on taste.
There were a variety of choices for where you could sit: outside, in a booth, around a table, near the window. My husband and I had a nice spot near the window. We purchased the Il Diavolo pizza and seafood linguine. Waiting time for food and service was good. These two items that we had were delicious: The linguine and seafood tasted fresh. The pizza actually delivered in taste and crust being a perfect balance of crunchy and not overdone -- my mouth is watering just thinking about it. There was a special on Prosecco and beer for $5 all day so that was good. Overall, with tip, for two people it was a bit pricey for us but this is one place for me that is among the best, if not best places I have ever been to in Toronto. I am almost certain that we will be going here again when the next special occasion presents itself!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.