I don't live in Victoria, but go the The Guild every time I am in the city. It is always great, the servers are friendly and courteous, the food is amazing, and the choice of beers is second to none.
Last week I was in Victoria & went to the Brewmaster's Dinner they have once a month. It was fabulous. Three courses with beer pairings for each course...and not just a small glass of beer, but a full 16 oz. all for $50 plus tip. Unbelievable value for the high quality of food and beer that are served.
My other favourite is the Prime Rib roast dinner they have every Sunday. I have been to The Guild 5 or 6 times when I have been in Victoria and have always had a great meal... love this place!