This was our third trip to Playa del Carmen. The first we stayed in an all-inclusive but the last two times stayed at wonderful Mahekal, which has a 2 meal plan. We often switch dinner for lunch so that we can go out at night, and on both trips, That's Amore was a multiple dining option. We were there 9 days on this trip, and ate at That's Amore three times - the pizza is that good! It is a thin crust, lite-on-the-sauce pizza just the way I like it. We get the margarita, which can't be beat. They bring some red pepper infused olive oil which you can put on the pizza, and that just sends it over the edge!
They also give you a fabulous appetizer of chopped tomato with olive oil on a delicious piece of bread - there is probably a name for this, but I just call it YUMMY.
We have always had a warm welcome and great service, so I am surprised by comments in other reviews. You just have to understand that the pace and customs are different, so don't be shy about calling the server over. You almost always have to request the bill in any restaurant in PDC.
The location is toward the south end of 5th Av, which is super convenient if you are staying at Mahekal or Las Palapas or the Royale. It is all patio dining with nice fans and great people watching on 5th Av.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.