We loved the Beach House. Cool place, the food was excellent- we had the spicy chickpeas (a HUGE portion), the smoked salmon bruchetta and the conch fritters. Loved the chickpeas and the salmon- the conch fritters were good but not the best we had. What sold us was the atmosphere. The view out from the bar is just spectacular. We went down to have lunch on the first visit and stayed for hours!
Prices- especially drinks- were a bit high, but we found that to be the case everywhere on the island. We stuck to Kalik- kept COLD in a cooler at the bar.
Also, the portions are huge so ask or plan for that. The bartender packed up to go boxes for us, no problem. Chickpeas are even better the next day.
The owner and bartenders/wait staff were all very friendly and chatty with us. No one blinked when my sand covered kid came dripping in. Just very laid back. I would advise anyone going to plan on staying an afternoon to enjoy the view and the perfect beach out front. The only problem I had with the Beach House was it was too far away from where we were staying. I echo the comment of an earlier poster- next time we are staying closer to the Beach House. Preferably make it there a 'pied and stay even longer