We are foodies and enjoy good food and don't mind paying for a culinary experience. We live close to NYC and have been to many fine restaurants there (Jean Georges, Le Bernardin, Daniel Boloud, etc). Therefore, on our recent trip to Atlantis, I reserved in all the fine restaurants (Bahamian Club, Mesa Grill, Martinique, etc). Went to BAhamian Club the first night. What a disappointment!!! First of all, the service is subpar, which I learned quickly that's the way it is in Bahamas. Fine, we just lowered our expectations on service. But the food had the quality of a diner or Ruby Tuesday!!!! Conch chowder was salty, fish was ordinary, like something I could have cooked at home myself. Dessert was not memorable. Worst of all, our son got sick that night. Stay away from this place. Not worth the money.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.