We stayed at Reefside villa in feb 2017. Our group was four adult couples and two teenagers. The layout of reefside was such that we all had beautiful rooms, private baths and complete privacy. The common areas were comfortable and spacious, dining room was great. Pool deck was large and very welcoming after a day at the beach. Quick 5 minute drive to Cruz Bay for groceries/dinner/drinks; 15-25 minute drive to Northside beaches. Catered To was very responsive to our two issues: one day the a/c did not work in two of the bedrooms, they had a repairman over to fix within 10 minutes of my call. On another night we had a power outtage which caused one room to lose water pressure. Again, this was fixed within a few minutes of my call.
Overall, we loved the villa and would return in a heartbeat!
This Villa was exactly what we hoped for and the private beach is awesome!!! The Catered To team were so nice and amazing to work with!! We will definitely be back!!