Thank goodness for Trip Advisor as we otherwise wouldn't have known about this place! We had visited the Starfish Market several times during our week stay this March, but there is no signage outside of the building to indicate that this deli exists! Once you get inside the building, there is a small sign indicating what's upstairs. We only tracked it down after our Villa manager mentioned it and I looked it up on TA. It's even better than we expected. The sandwich choices are really varied and creative, service was quick and our sandwiches were fresh and quite good. As another reviewer mentioned, the sandwiches are big enough to share. Definitely worth checking out, especially if you want a lower cost option to some of the pricier restaurant fare on the island. Would be perfect to take along for a beach day or hike.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.