We were seated on the outside deck overlooking the street, which was totally lovely on a lovely night. It appeared that most if not all the couples were seated there, with groups of younger people inside, perhaps so they could spread out more. Our service was shaky from the start, with one server (I wish I got her name) making up for it with her willingness to take our orders and for her friendliness. She was great. Our assigned server was totally perfunctory in his attitude, although he did nothing wrong per se. My husband started with 1 paella slider that he liked a lot. Then he had the jambalaya which he was totally disappointed with. The shrimp were highly seasoned for no good reason, and the rest of the dish was a meh. I had the ribs which were okay and the fries, which I hardly touched. The key lime pie was a nice dessert. Prices on St. John are just high for reasons listed elsewhere in these reviews. While I didn't think the dinners themselves warranted the prices, you've got to give the restaurant some slack for the nice ambience they provide. But would we go back? I'm pretty sure not.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.