I popped into Baked in the Sun twice during my stay in St. John. The first time we ordered coffees. Baked in the Sun was bustling- coffee is self serve so it didn't take that long to be handed a cup. The second time, we got coffees and bagels/sticky buns. The bagel was so-so. Almost stale, but not quite. The sticky bun, however, was not bad, and I'd order it again. We ordered the bagel toasted- the bagel was brought to our table, but not too quickly. As you will discover, food in Cruz Bay is much more expensive than on the mainland United States. Baked in the Sun was not the best, but not terrible, but a cheaper place to purchase a quick coffee.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.