We returned to St. John after visiting last June, and because Miss Lucy's was one of our favorite restaurants the first time we visited the island, we definitely planned to return. We were not disappointed. In my opinion, this restaurant has some of the best views on the island. It is a great casual atmosphere. We ordered conch fritters, steak wrap, seafood wrap and the jerk chicken wrap. The seafood wrap was so good, and our meal so enjoyable , that we actually ended up eating lunch twice at Miss Lucy's during the week. The seafood wrap and fries was our favorite. As others have mentioned, service was a little slower than other places (though we never waited more than an hour) but we didn't mind at all because of the spectacular views. If you are looking for a casual restaurant with first class views and friendly service, Miss Lucy's is a must!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.