The owner we rented from highly recommended Island Time. they have picnic tables that overlook the marina and the other islands. we ordered a large Vinny's pizza (super YUM), a sausage calazone, Italian Grinder sandwich and 1 mixed drink. it was $57 before tip for our famiy of 5 (kids 15, 11 & 8) we had left overs that were just as good the next day. it started to rain so they boxed it up and we took it back to our condo BUT not before other patrons offered for us to sit with them in the covered area :) .. we loved it enough to go back, we got the cheeseburger pizza, vinny's pizza and an italian grinder $55 to go. left overs again and so worth it. what a reasonable meal for our family of 5! these guys are just really relaxed and nice. i highly recommend eating here your first or second day so you can see how yummy it is then you can go back if you like.
they have 1/2 price pizza on monday night football games, $15 for a bucket of beer and wings (we didn't get it but that's what we think she said).
you park down below and walk up the stairs to level 3 or just one above the street level. it's on the waterside to park.