I think this restaurant is way overpriced for everything except for the lobsters.
My husband ordered some sort of fried fish. The one small piece of fish that came with the 2 smallest sides were $20. For that price they should really double the portion for the sides, even then it would still be a small portion. The fish and the potato wedges were forgettable, the vegetable side was good.
I wanted to order a whole lobster but they only had half of one left for lunch so I ended up paying $37 for half instead of $50 for a whole lobster. Nevertheless, it was huge and worth every penny. It was very meaty but not particularly sweet :( I also ordered a piña colada and it was the best I had on my vacation. To be fair, I don't like my drinks too strong so this drink was perfect for me.
Just a heads up, they add on a service fee for the kitchen, I thought that was strange.
I know that everything is more expensive on Anegada but it is especially so at this restaurant because of its location (connect to the infamous Lobolly Beach). Like most, people go here for lunch because it is convenient. If you have a car I might check out other dinning options.